David Lepeska | Kashmir Observer | Sunday April 15, 2007

Film Review of Sanjay Kak’s Jashn-e-Azadi

By David Lepeska

About an hour into Sanjay Kak’s documentary feature Jashn-e-Azadi, a wan, middle-aged Bandipora villager is asked by a visiting surveyor if she knows the identity of her son’s killers. The woman sighs heavily and greets the questioner with fathomless eyes.

“They came at night,” she says listlessly. “What can one say about dark times?”

Without adequate illumination, very little — a truism Mr. Kak proves with this film.

The director was inspired to make the feature-length documentary after visiting Srinagar during 2004 Independence Day celebrations and finding disinterested locals and mostly empty streets. Intended for an Indian audience, the film seeks to explain why Kashmiris still refuse to become part of the world’s largest democracy. In taking over two hours to present an argument any observer could outline in a few minutes, Jashn becomes just as meandering and diffuse as the discourse of your average Kashmiri. Mr. Kak tries valiantly to plumb the depths, but with little coherence and minus an overarching message, the truth stays mostly hidden.

The film opens on villagers running from a shooting in Bandipora, and the viewer is quickly engaged. But then as the narrator (Mr. Kak) recounts an abbreviated historical summary we are shown scenes of shikaras moving slowly through the backwaters of Dal. Why? We don’t know where they are going and there is no reason to bring up Dal, whose sad devastation deserves its own film (and several have already been made). The boats never appear again and but they are shown here for lengthy shots as Kak rushes through the background of the dispute: Sheikh Abdullah’s leadership; the devastation of Partition; land to the tiller leads to freedom; and then how with Indian mistreatment hope turned to disillusionment, then to mass resistance, and finally to armed struggle. Forty years of Kashmir history telescoped into a single, aloof sentence and we are deposited into the midst of the conflict as if onto a wooden raft on stormy open seas, without compass or paddle.

Which may be the director’s intention, but the filmmaking choices suggest a lack of clarity. Images clash and rub up against strange bedfellows, for instance. A father visits a martyr’s graveyard on a snowy Eid and can’t find his son’s grave. But back and forth cutting to archival footage of angry villagers and an empty Lal Chowk undermines the scene’s impact. And then suddenly tourists are snapping photos at Nishat and on top of a snowy hillock in Gulmarg, dubbing the Valley “paradise” and “heaven on earth.” The contradiction between the Indian perspective and the daily life of the average Kashmiris daily life is indeed shocking, but there is so little context that the message is musted. At the end of the film Indian visitors hold AK-47’s and pose for pictures with armed, camouflaged soldiers, as if mocking the state’s disputed status. If most Indians are as ignorant of the current situation and ongoing violence and anxiety in Kashmir, they do indeed need a wake-up call. This, however, is not it.

Undoubtedly, the film has considerable merit. The Valley is convincingly portrayed as overwhelmed and under siege. Several scenes of grief-wracked locals again brings home the devastation of the conflict, at both the personal and national levels. And in a short but potent scene of unmarked graves and burial in Kupwara, the current hot-button topic of encounter killings is addressed without hyperbole. “Bodies materialize as if from the earth and forest, part of Kashmir’s ledger of loss,” the narrator intones. The local in charge of burying the unidentified corpses is benumbed by the daily brutality. “Our hearts have turned to stone,” says the gravedigger. Expressionless, he adds, “Once we received a body without a head.”

A bhand pather performance – broad, comedic, self-flagellating – highlights how local perspectives of the persecution and oppression have changed over the decades and centuries. The mental fallout of the conflict is highlighted in an early section at the Psychiatric Medical Hospital. And the piercing irony of a scene in which Indian soldiers hands out radios to Kupwara village elders is hard to miss. “We want you to be able to listen to what’s going on in the world,” the lieutenant tells them.

But there’s no backbone, no structural skeleton to which these hunks of flesh and bone can adhere and form a complete and recognizable whole. Scenes jump from 2005 to 1992, from 2006 to 2000, and from 2003 to 1993, as if the year or the context does’nt matter. As if the last 19 years have been a vacuum in the Valley.

Such a view suggests little familiarity with nuances of recent life in Kashmir. But look around: at the budding protest theatre community, at successful demonstrations against unhealthy and illegal garbage dumping; at separatists’ involvement in roundtable discussions; at significant drops in violence and militancy and serious talk of troop withdrawal by key political players; at graphic novels on Kashmir militancy and films like Jashn screening in the heart of Srinagar. Late in the film an Indian motivational speaker is talking about change to a group of interested professionals in Delhi. “Once we go past resistance,” he tells the crowd, “then we start to explore.” Recent events on the ground suggest that time has arrived, while Jashn argues that locals are still stuck in first gear.

One would hope that a documentary about the conflict made by an experienced, highly regarded Pandit filmmaker would shed some light on the dispute — offer a comprehensive picture, uncover new insights, or take a fresh angle. Instead, darkness weighs heavy on the film. In portraying Kashmir as stagnant over the last two decades – as defiant, yes, but also hard-headed, benumbed and tied blindly to armed resistance, victim-hood, and any semblance of control – Mr. Kak ignores the visible progress, underestimates his subjects and leaves Kashmir in the dark.

Five years ago this film might’ve been groundbreaking. Today it’s old news.


Jashn-e-Azadi is available through various online outlets like amazon

You can now buy a DVD of the film, or Download it and watch
More than two years in the making, Jashn-e-azadi [How We Celebrate Freedom], is a feature length documentary by film-maker Sanjay Kak which explores the implications of the struggle for Azadi, for freedom, in the Kashmir valley.

Click here to watch the Trailer

As India celebrates the 60th anniversary of it's Independence, this provocative and quietly disturbing new film raises questions about freedom in Kashmir, and about the degrees of freedom in India.

And here is a short Interview with the film-maker.

This Jashn-e-Azadi blog is an open forum for conversations about the film, about Kashmir, and about Azadi itself.

For more information about screenings, sales and broadcast write to
jashneazadifilmATgmail.com

links

For dispatches from the present

Voices of protest can be found here or call you from here

Stone in my hand

In the season of solutions, the late Eqbal Ahmad's wise words have to be remembered

Kashmir blog has the best one line blog take on Kashmir - they call it paradise, I call it home.

Zarafshan is a Kashmiri blogger whose blog (and blogrolls) are "just ways of dispersing news, views and feelings!"

For a considered discussion on the vexed issue of Pandits in Kashmir see Kasheer. And for more on this Ephemeral Existence

And a discovery called Paradise Lost

RSS Kashmir via Greater Kashmir

  • An error has occurred; the feed is probably down. Try again later.

previews

Festival screenings

Thiruvananthapuram
May 26, 2008 / International Video Festival of Kerala
Munich
Apr 28, 2008 / Dok.Fest
Amsterdam
Feb 10, 2008 / Himalaya Film Festival
Amsterdam
Nov 28, 2007 / International Documentary Festival
Kathmandu
Oct 12, 2007 / Film South Asia
Delhi
July 22, 2007 / Osian’s Cinefan film festival

Previous Previews

London
7 Dec 2007 / School of Oriental & African Studies & Sacred Media Cow
Leeds
6 Dec 2007 / Workshop Theatre, School of English, University of Leeds
Egham, Surrey
3 Dec 2007 / Royal Holloway, University of London
New Delhi
26 Nov 2007 / Russian Centre of Science & Culture & Magic Lantern Foundation

New Jersey
Oct 5, 2007 / College of New Jersey
New York City
Oct 4, 2007 / Columbia School of Journalism
Austin
Oct 2, 2007 / University of Texas
Philadelphia
Sep 28, 2007 / Temple University
Philadelphia
Sep 27, 2007 / University of Pennsylvania
New York State
Sep 26, 2007 / Vassar College
New York City
Sep 25, 2007 / New School for Social Research
Boston
Sep 23, 2007 @ MIT
Toronto
Sep 22, 2007 / SALDA
Toronto
Sep 21, 2007 / University of Toronto
New Haven
Sep 20, 2007 / Yale University
Minneapolis
Sep 18, 2007 / University of Minnesota

Hyderabad
Aug 10, 2007 / Pure Docs, Prasad Preview, Banjara Hills

interrupted previews!! [[ MUMBAI ...
July 27, 2007 (Fri)
Vikalp: Films for Freedom @ Bhupesh Gupta Bhawan, 85 Sayani Road, Prabhadevi
July 30, 2007 (Mon)
Vikalp: Films for Freedom @ Prithvi House, Juhu...]]

Bangalore
July 14, 2007 / Institute of Agrl. Technologies, Queens Road
Bangalore
July 13, 2007 / Centre for Film & Drama, Millers Road
Nashik
June 13, 2007, Pandit Vishnu Digambar Paluskar Hall
Pune
June 12, 2007, National Film Archive of India Auditorium
Guwahati
May 29, 2007, Blue Moon Hotel
Shillong
May 26, 2007, Assam Club, Laban
Patna
May 12, 2007, Hindi Bhavan Hall
Srinagar
March 31, 2007, Tagore Hall
New Delhi
March 23, 2007, Sarai-CSDS
New Delhi
March 13, 2007, India Habitat Center

a

stats

  • 133,642 visitors

%d bloggers like this: